New City Players (NCP) – recognized for staging transformative theater that addresses complicated social issues and building community – can now add “environmental advocate” to its hot topic list. You might recall seeing (or reading my review of) Rachel Bublitz’s “headline news” satire Burst and its imposing set wall of “recyclable” plastic bottles that closed the company’s 10th Anniversary Season. That environmental warning of a play exposed both the pervasiveness and health risks of microplastics in our waterways (and everywhere else) while spotlighting how even the most dedicated of scientists can fall victim to hubris and corporate greed.
And now New City Players opens its 11th Season, titled “America at 250: What Holds Us Together When We’re Pushed Apart?” with a powerful new take on an ageless classic that once again has an environmental issue, specifically water, at its core. And, as usual, the humans in charge are pushed apart by opposing opinions on how to handle their little spa town’s sudden water contamination crisis. Amy Herzog’s contemporary reimagining of pioneer playwright Henrik Ibsen’s legendary 1882-play, AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE, debuted on Broadway in 2024, winning the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Adaptation. It was also nominated for five Tonys, including Best Revival of a Play. I have a feeling that New City Players’ explosive Florida premiere of Herzog’s version of Ibsen’s play will be on the short list for many of our local awards as well.
Starting with the play’s director, Ali Tallman, fresh off Silver Palm and Carbonell Awards for her direction of The 39 Steps. When the NCP ensemble member was first tasked with directing Ibsen’s popular classic, you can be sure the dramaturg in her got busy. As she explains in the hefty, paper (yay!) program. (I love how much educational background about the period, playwright, players, etc. are included.)
While immersing herself in the text, Tallman says she considered “Ibsen’s original, Arthur Miller’s, Amy Herzog ‘s, and my own adaptation. I’m thrilled we [in discussion with NCP’s producing artistic director Tim Davis] landed on Herzog’s version, with its streamlined language and cheeky comedic sensibility. Through them all, I found myself returning to a question familiar to Americans today: what is truth, and who gets to decide it?”

It’s a core focus of the drama and a question that will linger with you long after the show. Yet one more reason why Henrik Ibsen, premier playwright of the 19th century (and beyond), extolled as “the father of modern drama” and often put on par with Shakespeare (Ibsen plays rank only second to the Bard’s in frequency of production) continues to be so popular. The Norwegian playwright’s laser focus on the intersection of character, politics, business, and morality in society – and the choices and compromises one makes when those interests collide – continues to challenge Western Civilization. This is likely true for each generation but, perhaps like my forebears, I can’t help feeling that Americans are being challenged in this moment as never before.
It’s almost freaky how Ibsen’s play about a small coastal town in early 1880’s Norway, facing economic and environmental challenges, so closely mirrors what’s happening in our country today. Erin Brockovich first made clean water a public issue decades ago with her crusade against PG&E for years of toxic chemical release into the drinking water of Hinkley, a small CA town. Still health concerns, particularly lead seepage from old pipes like those contaminating the drinking water of Flint, Michigan, and many other American cities, continue.

Ibsen’s portrayal of how five self-interested “pillars” of the community vs. one stubborn, science-based doctor (and his two unpopular allies) deal with the town’s imminent health crisis is shiver-inducing in its resonance. In fact (like many “updated” Shakespeare plays), if you set An Enemy in any current American rural town, equip the living room with at least 20th century furniture and give the eight characters a 2020’s wardrobe makeover (from Casey Sacco’s spot-on costume & HMU design), you’d never guess this play wasn’t written by a contemporary American playwright.
But we can easily make the connection … and perhaps it’s more palatable to see ourselves in people who, at least outwardly, appear different from us. I especially loved how New City Players’ creative team leaned into the Norwegian Wood visual (and even musical) experience because their stage set design by scenic designer Michael McClain, scenic builders MNM Builds, with props and set dressing by Jameelah Bailey, was an absolute wonder to behold!

I don’t remember ever watching a completely visible dining-room scene through a wall of glass-paneled “windows” one minute, then having that room vanish when those, now external, windows reveal majestic forest expanses or gently falling snow. It’s soon obvious why this rural location was considered an ideal setting for a spa featuring healing Baths and nature relaxation. Much of that northern magic is also due to the sustained efforts of lighting designer Desiraé Merritt and sound designer Andrea Guerdo-Cuao. Striking Norwegian folk tunes played before the show, and at intervals between scenes, add to the sense of time and place.
The play opens to what we’d call a dinner party in the very busy and welcoming household of Dr. Thomas Stockmann – physician, scientist, Medical Director of the town’s Baths … and the play’s central character. Ben Sandomir plays the good doctor with great passion, sensitivity, delusional innocence, and ultimate rage at his beloved town’s stupidity (in not believing that malignant, invisible-to-the-naked-eye microbes can kill and make them ill). He’s also sickened and disheartened when respected members of the community turn against him – recklessly placing concerns about their personal livelihood, reputation, and the town’s future prosperity above the health of its citizens and any spa visitors from afar.
This includes Dr. Thomas’s snide and disrespectful brother, Mayor Peter Stockmann, who runs the town with an iron glove (and feels his brother doesn’t grovel in sufficient appreciation for his providing him with a fancy house and the spa director’s position). Peter Stockmann, who also serves as Chairman of the Baths, is ultimately responsible for their investors going with cheaper, too-low piping that his brother had warned against and caused the ground water contamination. He holds a vested financial and political interest in keeping any health dangers secret.
Never were two brothers more different in character and values. (Well, maybe Cain and Abel.) Sandomir as Dr. Thomas is constantly superb in his role of concerned, then activist citizen, loving father, and faithful appreciative friend to Captain Horster (a small but important role as staunch ally and the family’s ultimate savior, movingly enacted by Timothy Mark Davis). While obstreperous Ryan Didato, in his prominent role as Mayor Peter Stockmann, provides a far too believable, and recognizable, picture of the self-important, self-centered, greedy, rude, slimy and sneaky political hack.
The third member of the Stockmann family is the doctor’s lovely and caring, young-adult daughter, Petra. While employed as a dedicated elementary school teacher by day, we always see her in her second, “family night shift,” patiently catering to their home’s many visitors (the constant knocks on the door even surpass my most annoying text ding days) with food and drink, while attempting to calm her father’s rages while also seeing to the needs of her younger kid brother (who is often mentioned but never seen).
Petra fully takes over the traditional female household responsibilities after the death of her mother, several months earlier. But she’s also very much her father’s daughter – a firebrand who completely agrees with his decision to speak truth to save lives, no matter the personal cost. I love how she resents having to teach “lies” in approved classroom curriculum and, when ultimately fired (along with anyone who took her dad’s side) looks to forward to starting a school of her own where her little brother won’t be bullied for his father’s “sins” and all hoodlums, misfits and the scrappiest kids would be welcome to learn to think for themselves.
Outspoken and caring Petra has writing aspirations as well but puts her journalism dreams aside when she’s savvy enough to realize the town’s newspaper editor wants more from her than column contributions. (Sadly, when it comes to women rising in the ranks at the workplace, sexual harassment at the office is never old news.) Petra Stockmann is marvelously portrayed by Marla Lopez, and I couldn’t help but feel for her in perhaps the sole, somewhat dated, role of Hausfrau – though I’m sure this is still a sexist fact of life in many conservative circles.
